ISC
  • #ISC25
  • Privacy Policy
  • Late-Breaking Science
  • Daily Coverage
  • Industry Highlights
  • Photo Gallery
  • Program
Topics
  • Late-Breaking Science
  • Daily Coverage
  • Industry Highlights
  • Photo Gallery
  • Program
Resources
  • #ISC25
  • Privacy Policy
User Tools
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Accessibility Statement
Twitter X icon YouTube iconPinterest iconLinkedIn icon
Feb 10th, 2020

Code Blue During the COVID-19 Pandemic

Paul S. Chan, Robert A. Berg, Vinay M. Nadkarni
Originally published 7 Apr 2020 | Circulation: Cardiovascular Quality and Outcomes

Getty Images 1214643007

The surging COVID-19 pandemic has raised ethical and moral dilemmas that Western nations with first-rate medical care facilities rarely confront—how to best allocate standard life-saving medical resources when escalating demand outstrips supply. Sadly, these quandaries are familiar challenges in resource-poor countries. What makes this pandemic notable is that the scope and number of reported cases have been primarily in First World nations, raising questions in some settings about the use of emergency treatments like resuscitation care for in-hospital cardiac arrest (IHCA). This perspective reviews the debate around these ethical and moral dilemmas more broadly but focuses specifically on IHCA and the response of the medical community.

To date, the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic in the U.S. has varied widely by region. Already in certain areas of the U.S., hospitals have run out of intensive care unit (ICU) beds and mechanical ventilators for patients and personal protective equipment (PPE) for healthcare providers. Like Italian physicians in Lombardy before them, physicians are faced with decisions about rationing of healthcare resources. Deontological ethics emphasize that each person is valuable and should have an equal chance of receiving life-saving care (i.e., “first-come, first-served”). However, this framework in some instances is becoming an exercise of abstract argumentation as clinicians may be forced to apply utilitarian ethics to prioritize saving the most lives in settings with extremely limited resources.

But the disconnect is that, to date, physicians in the U.S. have had the luxury to practice medicine with an individual rather than a societal perspective. We have learned from and coveted our caring relationships with fellow human beings, and we have been largely spared from confronting medical scarcity at the bedside. By nature, training, and experience, we practice medicine in an ethical framework of deontology and not utilitarianism. Yet that equation changes when facing two patients with equal need but insufficient resources to care for both. Choosing between which patient receives life-saving care when the alternative outcome is certain death presents a situation of imminent moral distress.


The full text of this article is available at https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/CIRCOUTCOMES.120.006779

Interesting Stories
NIH Stroke Scale
Sponsored by American Heart Association/American Stroke Association
NIH Stroke Scale
Stroke Risks and Prevention
Sponsored by American Heart Association/American Stroke Association
Stroke Risks and Prevention
Cholesterol for Professionals
Sponsored by American Heart Association/American Stroke Association
Cholesterol for Professionals
Connection Between Sleep and Cardiovascular Disease
Sponsored by American Heart Association/American Stroke Association
Connection Between Sleep and Cardiovascular Disease
More Content
Getty Images 1209679031
archives
Blood Pressure De-Regulation and Renal Function Are Main Determinants of COVID-19 Mortality
Nov 3rd, 2020
Getty Images 635821036 (1)
archives
Paroxysmal Hypertension Associated With Urination
Aug 21st, 2020
Role Of Rare 1179119573
archives
Role of Rare and Low-Frequency Variants in Gene-Alcohol Interactions on Plasma Lipid Levels
Jun 8th, 2020
Genotype Guided Dosing 1179992727
archives
Genotype-Guided Dosing of Warfarin in Chinese Adults
Jun 8th, 2020
Alcohol Consumption 1179303998
archives
Alcohol Consumption and Cardiovascular Disease
May 5th, 2020
Maxresdefault 5ec05f63f3ede
archives
Quality Improvement in Rural Settings
Feb 10th, 2020
Maxresdefault 5ebedc02d0306
archives
AHA-ISPOR Joint Session on Real-World Evidence
Feb 10th, 2020
Getty Images 1216865680
archives
Navigating Health Care Supply Shortages During the COVID-19 Pandemic
Feb 10th, 2020
Getty Images 1000912070
archives
Role of Data Registries in the Time of COVID-19
Feb 10th, 2020
Getty Images 1132235083
archives
Burden and Consequences of Financial Hardship From Medical Bills Among Nonelderly Adults With Diabetes Mellitus in the United States
Feb 6th, 2020